Oral Argument on Monday in Case of First Impression

A panel of three Judges of the Indiana Court of Appeals will hear oral argument Monday afternoon, December 12, 2011, starting at 1 PM in the Indiana Supreme Courtroom, in a media law case of first impression in Indiana.

I’ve previously written in this blog about The Indianapolis Star v. Jeffrey M. Miller, et al., Case No. 49A02-1103-PL-234.   The novel question is whether and under what circumstances a litigant can compel a non-party newspaper to disclose the identity of an internet user who posted anonymous comments to a news story published in the newspaper’s online edition.  Courts in other jurisdictions that have addressed the question have followed a multi-part standard adopted or modified from Dendrite International v. Doe, No. A-2774-00T3,  775 A.2d 776, N.J. App. Div. (July 11, 2001).

The Indianapolis Star is appealing a Marion County Superior Court order requiring the newspaper to comply with the plaintiffs’ subpoena demanding the identity of an unnamed person who posted under the pseudonym, “DownWithTheColts.”  In the underlying lawsuit, Plaintiffs Jeffrey and Cynthia Miller allege that Mr. Miller’s former employer, Junior Achievement, Junior Achievement’s current president (Miller’s successor), and others defamed him by accusing him of financial mismanagement (or worse) in connection with certain Junior Achievement projects.  The Indianapolis Star covered the controversy and its online publication of its news stories attracted a number of anonymous, online comments.

 In opposing the subpoena, the Indianapolis Star has invoked the Journalists’ Shield Law, limitations on third-party discovery, and constitutional protections for anonymous speech under both the First Amendment and Article I, Section 9 of the Indiana Constitution.  Courts have recognized that anonymity does have value, and those who comment on public controversies often have legitimate reasons for remaining anonymous.

About Bose McKinney & Evans LLP

Bose McKinney & Evans LLP is a business law firm, headquartered in Indianapolis, Indiana, serving both publicly held and privately held businesses, governmental entities and high-growth industries. Our clients include Fortune 100 companies, international manufacturers, national and regional financial institutions, agribusinesses, sports teams, university-incubated start-ups, media, utilities, cities and schools, to name a few. We strive to build strong relationships with our clients as key business advisors, to exceed expectations in the quality of our work, to be knowledgeable about our clients’ businesses and sectors, to be responsive to service needs and to continually seek to improve the delivery of client services. Our ultimate focus is on our clients.
This entry was posted in First Amendment, Internet and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s